Entry 3: Interview with an ELL Teacher
For my
English Language Learner Interview, I chose to interview my cousin Farwa. Farwa
has been teaching in Alief ISD for 3 years now, and has always had English Language
Learners in her classroom. There were many things that she mentioned that I
could relate back to what we are learning in Second Language Acquisition.
She explains
how she believes that her English Language Learners have most difficulty with comprehension
and in subjects such as reading and writing due to their vocabulary bank. In
other words it is the size of their vocabulary, “the total number of words
known and represented in long-term memory”, that contributes to their struggle
in comprehension. (Ortega 2013, 88).
I think it is
interesting to see all of the different points of view and experiences when it
comes to this question. After the interview, Farwa and I in fact kept talking
about her experience with ELLs, and she mentioned something that she did not
get to in the interview. She said that sometimes it depends on each child and their
background. This is also heavily dependent on their economic background and if
the student has had stable schooling without displacement or frequent moving
from one residence to another, which can directly impact their learning. Farwa
works at a title 1 school, and the ELL students that she has seen, struggle
mostly with speaking, reading, and writing. As always, there are many factors
involved in each ELL student and their struggles such as family life, health,
and economic status at her title 1 school.
Ortega, Lourdes. Understanding Second Language
Acquisition. Routledge, 2015.
Click here to watch my interview.
Aleena, the mention of Ortega's vocabulary bank reminds me of his other points on comprehension and how it connects to motivation (2011). After all, students rarely retain information if they do not want to learn the material presented to them. Additionally, your inclusion of the topic of background especially interests me. My senior thesis tackles backgrounds as a point of diversity in students' classrooms. I discuss the implications of backgrounds influencing students' achievement levels. Would you say that a person's background ultimately decides their motivation to learn a subject, for instance, second-language acquisition?
ReplyDeleteWhat are some techniques or methods of teaching we can use in order to combat any negative influences in this case? Or would you disagree with backgrounds determining a person's personal motivation levels?
Hi Ila! I do believe that a students' background and home life may affect their level of motivation in school. They may be struggling with several different aspects of their life such as home life or financial stability that may reflect their priorities. Some of our students may not even have their basic needs being met, therefore, focusing on school is the last thing they are worried about. It is our responsibility as educators to understand and get to know our students, and try to help bring up their motivation levels in class by creating a warm and welcoming classroom environment. If we instill trust into our students, they will be more motivated to become successful learners in our classroom, a place where they feel safe and encouraged to learn. I am a strong believer of teachers holding a tremendous amount of influence in the classroom, and often we underestimate how much we can contribute to the success of our students.
Deletefinancial instability* :)
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
DeleteAleena, you are absolutely right when it comes to environmental factors having major impacts on student success! I wrote a paper last semester discussing this very issue, as well as the consequences of teachers who do not adequately pay attention to such details. Ortega values a strong support network for students, and I agree that such a sense of community allows for students to become high achievers (2011). I also love your point on creating strong ties with our students, as I feel like healthy, stable relationships are what help our students succeed most often.
DeleteAleena, your interview was very intriguing. When your interviewee discussed her observations of motivation and avoidance in her students, I drew some connections to Ortega's text. Specifically, Ortega discusses the topic of avoidance and its role in research studies and how it impacts the level of success individuals may display. The studies Ortega refers to show that certain individuals in one study formed fewer relative clauses in their writing over individuals with other first languages. While the results of the study initially showed a higher success and accuracy rate for certain individuals, its was determined after closer examination that the more 'accurate' individuals made fewer attempts to use relative clauses in their writing. Likewise, those who had shown more mistakes make more attempts at including relative clauses in their writing. To conclude, Ortega stated that avoidance can have a negative impact on language development (Ortega, 2013, p.40).
ReplyDeleteTo connect back to your interview, I thought it was important that she talked about avoidance and that she was aware of this occurring with some of her students so that she could better assist them and motivate them to attempt to speak the language more.
Hi Morgan, great observation. I absolutely agree with you about how avoidance can have a negative impact on students' learning. However I think it relates directly back to the fear and intimidation of being rejected. If we as educators make our students feel comfortable to answer a question, and be okay with getting the answer wrong, they will not be avoiding questions as much. I think it is great of Farwa to recognize this in her students and that she is aware that there needs to be some change happening in her classroom.
DeleteAleena,
ReplyDeleteThank you for sharing your interview and reflection! You are the second individual who has interviewed a teacher who stated that English Language Learners struggle most with comprehension. However, you are the first person I have read/watched that has mentioned the size of ELL's vocabulary bank directly correlating to the struggles of these students in specific subjects. This makes complete sense! I was reading Ortega and she states that in L1 a 5-year-old child begins school with an established vocabulary of approximately 5,000 word families. Whereas our L2 users, new vocabulary presents a formidable challenge as they need to learn about 3,000 new words in order to minimally follow conversations in the L2, and about 9,000 new word families if they want to be able to read novels or newspapers in the L2 (Ortega, 2013, p.88). Taking that into account, whoa that is a lot of words to learn! Our L1 have been able to take years to establish their vocabulary banks, while our L2 may be just getting dipping their feet in the water. It is no wonder that they struggle with comprehension. It will take our ELL's some time to establish a words meaning and store it in the long-term memory. I think with time, exposure, motivation, etc. our ELL's can grow to be successful in their L2.
Ortega, L. (2013). Understanding second language acquisition. London and New York: Routledge.
Hi Amanda! Yes! Your'e absolutely right. I think we often as educators have very high expectations for our students - which is a great thing - however we tend to forget that our ELLs are just now learning a new language. They need a tremendous amount of support from us to help them through the process of learning an L2. I remember observing an ELL student in ST1 whose vocabulary bank was very limited. He was in second grade, and had been at this school for 3 years at the time I joined the classroom. However, he was not receiving any ESL support, and I was in awe. He needed support in order to better his second language skills, and I believe he was being held back from his fullest potential.
DeleteHi Aleena! Great interview! I found it interesting that you mentioned that your cousin always has a classroom with ELLs. This last semester, during my student teaching 1, my classroom had 12 out of 18 students classified as ELLs in a first grade, self-contained, general classroom and I too was in Alief ISD. I thought it was interesting that she mentions the struggle that ELLs face when it comes to vocabulary because my interviewee also mentioned the same struggle with her ELLs. Ortega mentions that “vocabulary knowledge strength concerns the relative ability to use a given known word productively or to recognize it passively” which makes it difficult to really teach vocabulary because it is more linked to long term memory than cognition (Ortega, 2013, p.88). What methods of teaching do you think we could use as future educators to really combat the issue of vocabulary in an effective manner?
ReplyDeleteAlexis, I liked your comment regarding Aleena's post. I too am interested in learning teaching strategies to implement in my classroom to assist our ELLs with vocabulary comprehension. I would love a variety of ideas that teachers have found effective. Yes, at a fundamental level, a word is established in long-term memory when the link between form and its meaning is made. Knowing a word means a lot more: it includes the strength, size, and depth of the knowledge represented in memory (Ortega, 2013, p.88). Our primary vocabulary is in our L1 and we have been learning since we were infants. Our ELLs our now in an environment where they must learn L2 words/vocabulary in a short amount of time. I cannot imagine the struggle that these children go through. Thus why I too am interested in finding ways to assist them in optimal learning.
DeleteOrtega, L. (2013). Understanding second language acquisition. London and New York: Routledge.
Hi Alexis and Amanda. I really like the questions both of you bring up. I think that consistency and practice with our ELLs is key. A few highly effective strategies that I am a huge fan of for ELLs, and in fact all students, is sentence stems. allowing students to write sentence stems in their notebook and reference them repeatedly, will help their vocabulary bank grow. Also, including visuals for ELL's also helps a great deal.
DeleteHello Aleena and Amanda! So another strategy that I have seen to be useful in the classroom is the use of cognates when a student is learning English. Since you mentioned that our primary vocabulary is in our L1 we must find a way to integrate what our students already know and build upon that knowledge. Often times, “there are many relevant cognates, that is, words that have a common origin and therefore have similar form and meaning in the two related languages (e.g. redundant in English and redundante in Spanish) (Ortega, 2013, p.48).” Utilizing these cognates can be useful to a large variety of students who speak a large variety of languages
DeleteAleena, thank you for sharing your interview with Farwa. When I had my interview with Melissa, she also stated that her English language learning students had the most difficulty with vocabulary. Ortega talks about how the words we know the meaning of and can use (our vocabulary) is stored in our long-term memory. He also mentions how language learners know more words receptively, they recognize them but don’t know what they mean, than productively, meaning they know what it means and are able to use it (Ortega 2011, pg.88). I believe this is because second language learners have more trouble storing these words in their long-term memory.
ReplyDeleteReference:
Ortega, L. (2011). Understanding second language acquisition. Routledge.
Hi Haylee! I completely agree. This makes so much sense. Your statement directly correlates to the two points that Farwa made in her interview. The vocabulary bank and comprehension are both connected to one another. If students are not able to comprehend the material, they may be struggling with not understanding the vocabulary words, which results in a smaller vocabulary bank.
Delete